Design Evaluation System that Uses Evaluation Indices Extracted from Comments of Design Award Juries : A Study on Construction of Quality Chart Evaluation/Diagnostic System (2)

• Sogabe Haruka

  Kyushu University

• Morita Yoshitsugu

  Kyushu University

• Ishibashi Shinsuke

  Kyushu University

Bibliographic Information

Other Title

• デザイン賞の審査講評から抽出した評価指標を用いた評価システムの提案 : クオリティカルテ評価・診断システム構築に関する研究(2)

Abstract

Design evaluation indices applicable to a range of products were created and trialed in order to identify evaluation gaps assumed to exist between the following three user groups; designers, providers and end users. Design evaluation indices were created through a process of eliciting items considered to be important in evaluation for design awards, organizing these items logically and editing them into prototypical short, simple phrases. These were then revised through various pilot studies and polished to form the final design evaluation indices. The design evaluation indices were used in evaluation studies to show the existence of gaps in design evaluation between the user groups. Evaluation gaps were frequently apparent, particularly among designers, and we suggest that further examination of the causes of the gaps could be beneficial for product development.

Journal

• Bulletin of Japanese Society for the Science of Design

  Bulletin of Japanese Society for the Science of Design 56 (1), 55-64, 2009

  Japanese Society for the Science of Design

Keywords

• Design Evaluation
• Evaluation Indices
• Good Design

Details

• CRID: 1390282680386726272
• NII Article ID: 110007331080
• NII Book ID: AN00150292
• DOI: 10.11247/jssdj.56.55_1
• ISSN: 21865221
• ISSN: 09108173
• Text Lang: ja
• Data Source:
  • JaLC
  • CiNii Articles
  • KAKEN
• Abstract License Flag: Disallowed