中井正一「委員会の論理」(1936)における嘘言の媒介について  [in Japanese] About the communication mediated by lie in "the Logic of the Committee"(1936) of Masakazu NAKAI  [in Japanese]

Access this Article

Search this Article

Author(s)

Abstract

<p><tt>和文要約</tt> <tt>中井正一の「委員会の論理」</tt>(1936)<tt>における嘘言の媒介には後藤宏行</tt>(1965)<tt>,ついで針生一郎・松岡正剛</tt>(1982)<tt>が言及し,両者は嘘言によるコミュニケーションの発展を肯定的に把握した.他方,荒瀬豊</tt>(1979)<tt>は中井における嘘言の克服を強調した.しかし「委員会の論理」を仔細に読むとテクストは双方を支持し,嘘言が遍在する点を本稿は論じる.</tt> <tt>「委員会の論理」は,連載時の『世界文化』編集後記で元原稿を紙幅の関係で圧縮するように依頼した旨記され,中井の既存の諸論考の議論を補わないと理解しがたい.</tt> <tt>中井の重要概念,基礎射影及びコプラという言葉は「委員会の論理」でそれぞれ一つの節で僅かしか現れないが,先行あるいは後続する彼の諸論考と重ね合わせると,それらは嘘言の文脈で理解できる.また「委員会の論理」の本題とされる十六節のループ状のモデルにも嘘言は媒介する.</tt> <tt>以上のように「委員会の論理」において嘘言が遍在することを本稿は論じ,難解な「委員会の論理」の理解をやや明快にする一助となることを目指す.</tt></p>

<p>About the description of lies in "the Logic of the Committee"(1936) of Masakazu NAKAI, Hiroyuki GOTO (1965) and Ichiro HARIU & Seigo MATSUOKA (1982) regarded the lies as useful for the development of social communication. On the other hand, Yutaka ARASE (1979) emphasized the theme of overcoming the lies in NAKAI's all works and his life. However, when we read "the Logic of the Committee" carefully, the text of it supports the useful side of lies and we find the reference of the merits of lies latent but ubiquitous in the text. In the postscript of the no.14 of World Cultures (Sekai Bunka) in which "the Logic of the Committee" was compiled, the editor had expressed having urged NAKAI to compress his existing manuscripts due to the space. Although 'a basic and veritable projection' and 'absence of copula', which both are important concepts of NAKAI's other works, appear only once in "the Logic of the Committee", we could understand these concepts in the context of lies, if we overlap them with his preceding or succeeding works. Lies also involve the looped models of the 16th section, which is 'the main section' (Shunpei UEYAMA) of "the Logic of the Committee". Owing to these interpretations, this article aims to help us to understand the complicated text of "the Logic of the Committee" more easily.</p>

Journal

  • Journal of Information and Media Studies

    Journal of Information and Media Studies 16(1), 41-69, 2018

    Japan Society for Information and Media Studies

Codes

  • NII Article ID (NAID)
    130006464173
  • NII NACSIS-CAT ID (NCID)
    AA11845126
  • Text Lang
    JPN
  • Article Type
    journal article
  • ISSN
    1348-5857
  • NDL Article ID
    029017060
  • NDL Call No.
    Z71-K73
  • Data Source
    NDL  IR  J-STAGE 
Page Top