Plato's dialectic at play : argument, structure, and myth in the Symposium
Author(s)
Bibliographic Information
Plato's dialectic at play : argument, structure, and myth in the Symposium
Pennsylvania State University Press, c2004
Available at / 5 libraries
-
No Libraries matched.
- Remove all filters.
Note
Bibliography: p. [241]-254
Includes index
Description and Table of Contents
Description
The Symposium is one of Plato's most accessible dialogues, an engrossing historical document as well as an entertaining literary masterpiece. By uncovering the structural design of the dialogue, Plato's Dialectic at Play aims at revealing a Plato for whom the dialogical form was not merely ornamentation or philosophical methodology but the essence of philosophical exploration. His dialectic is not only argument; it is also play.
Careful analysis of each layer of the text leads cumulatively to a picture of the dialogue's underlying structure, related to both argument and myth, and shows that a dynamic link exists between Diotima's higher mysteries and the organization of the dialogue as a whole. On this basis the authors argue that the Symposium, with its positive theory of art contained in the ascent to the Beautiful, may be viewed as a companion piece to the Republic, with its negative critique of the role of art in the context of the Good. Following Nietzsche's suggestion and applying criteria developed by Mikhail Bakhtin, they further argue for seeing the Symposium as the first novel.
The book concludes with a comprehensive reevaluation of the significance of the Symposium and its place in Plato's thought generally, touching on major issues in Platonic scholarship: the nature of art, the body-soul connection, the problem of identity, the relationship between mythos and logos, Platonic love, and the question of authorial writing and the vanishing signature of the absent Plato himself.
Table of Contents
Contents
Introduction
1. Apollodorus's Prologue: An Imitation of an Imitation
1.1 The Historical Frame
1.2 Apollodorus and Mimetic Narrative
1.3 The Force of Hybris
1.4 Malakos versus Manikos: Soft or Mad?
1.5 Anachronisms?
2. Aristodemus's Prologue: The Destruction and Transformation of the Factual Frame of Reference
2.1 The Story
2.2 Sufficiency and Beauty: Emerging Criteria for Judgment
2.3 The Spatial Order?
2.4 Mimetic versus Hubristic: The Destruction of the Factual Narrative
2.5 Sophistic Education in the Context of Other Dialogues: Protagoras, Phaedo, Republic
2.6 Between Religious Observance and the Cycle of Opposites
2.7 "The Father of the Discourse"
3. The Order of the Speeches: Formulating the Problem
3.1 Eros
3.2 Encomium
3.3 The Problem of the Significance of the Early Speeches
4. From Character to Speech: The Early Speeches and Their Significance
4.1 Phaedrus: The Ardent Apprentice, but Confused Mythologue
4.2 Pausanias: The Sophistic Sociologue
4.3 Hiccups and Eryximachus, the Homogenic Doctor-Scientist
4.4 Aristophanes: The Poet as Educator
4.4.1 Aristophanes' Speech and Socrates' Criticism of Mimetic Art in the Republic
4.4.2 The Possibility of Anachronism and Plato's Vanishing Signature
4.4.3 Aristophanes' Speech as a Parody of Philosophical Dialectic
4.4.4 Aristophanes' Speech and Individual Identity
4.4.5 Aristophanes' Hiccups Revisited
4.5 Agathon: The Sophistic Theologue as the "Climax" of an Unselfcritical Tradition
4.5.1 Advance over the Previous Speakers?
4.5.2 Agathon as Theologue Without Need
4.5.3 The Shadow of the "Good": Agathon's Portrait in the Context of the Republic
4.6 Conclusion
5. Diotima-Socrates: Mythical Thought in the Making
5.1 Introduction: The Problem
5.2 The Elenchus of Agathon and the Question of Truth
5.3 The Role of Diotima
5.4 Eros-Daimon
5.5 Diotima and the Art of Mythmaking Revisited: The Birth of Eros
5.6 Love: Relation or Substance?
5.7 Rhetoric and Dialectic
5.8 Criticism of Aristophanes and Agathon
5.9 The Curious Case of Procreation in the Beautiful
5.10 The Concluding Sections of the Lesser Mysteries
5.11 Preliminary Conclusion
6. The Greater Mysteries and the Structure of the Symposium So Far
6.1 The Movement of Ascent: Structure
6.2 The Movement of Ascent and the Earlier Speeches
6.3 Immortality and God-Belovedness
6.4 Overall Conclusion
6.4.1 "Platonic Love": The View So Far
7. Alcibiades and the Conclusion of the Symposium: The Test and Trial of Praise
7.1 The Figure of Dionysus and the Face of Socrates
7.2 The Role of Alcibiades
7.3 The Test of Praise
7.4 The Trial of Praise
7.5 Eros, the Tyrant, and His Revelers
7.6 Identity and Diversity: The Uniqueness of Socrates
7.7 Logoi Opened Up: An Image for the Symposium?
7.8 The Concluding Scenes: Rest and the Self-Motion of Thought-"Socrates Standing Seeking"
8. Conclusion: Plato's Dialectic at Play
8.1 Character, Voice, and Genre
8.2 Bakhtin and the Dialogical Character of Novelistic Discourse
8.3 The Symposium as the First "Novel" of Its Kind in History
8.4 Plato's Dialectic at Play: Art, Reason, and Understanding
8.5 Plato's Positive View of Art
8.6 Structure, Myth, and Argument
8.7 Soul-Body and Human Identity
8.8 "Platonic Love" and "Plato"
Select Bibliography
Index
by "Nielsen BookData"
